New Liberal Small Business Tax Will Cripple Business Owners

It’s time for Liberal to stop their tax and spend politics, and its time they stop playing with our economy. We need a real plan for economic growth, and sadly it seems Justin has none.

Bill Morneau
Donate All donations go towards promoting independent journalism and this month's charity.

Justin Trudeau insisted Wednesday that his government won’t back down on a controversial plan to end tax provisions that he says provide wealthy small business owners an unfair advantage.

“I want to be clear, People who make $50,000 a year should not pay higher taxes than people who make $250,000 a year.” – Justin Trudeau  

So what is this controversial plan?

Finance Minister Bill Morneau launched a 75-day consultation period for three proposed changes:

  • The curtailment of “income sprinkling,”
  • The curbing of “passive investment income,” which the government describes as the investment of money left in a corporation, for purposes other than to invest directly in growth.
  • The conversion of a corporation’s regular income into capital gains, which typically attract a lower tax rate.

These three changes have received criticism from mom and pop shops, doctors, and large business’, with most criticism being aimed at the first two aspects of the plan.

Income sprinkling

Income splitting is a method by which business owners shift a portion of income to family members, either through salary or dividends. Although it may seem unfair at first it is a method by which small family owned ventures manage to operate when facing ever increasing competition from large scale market disruptors such as Amazon.

For example, a husband and spouse who share ownership within a business would now be forced to receive lower dividend payments and have to pay higher taxes. In the case of a stay at home mother, this act directly devalues the labor she performs at home. The stay at home mother receives 50% of the corporation as she takes the risk with her spouse and divides the labor of the family unit. By acting as if the spouse is not a legitimate partner, you either break down that family relationship or devalue the labor of a stay at home spouse.

A great example of this can be found in recent CBC article which quotes an Albertan business owner:

“If, God forbid, I divorced my wife of 33 years tomorrow, the government would say that half this business belongs to her. She stayed home and raised our three children, she’s participated in the risk, the whole family did. So why shouldn’t she be paid.”

Alberta’s Economic Funk

Alberta has been mired in a deep economic funk for several years.

He’s had to meet payroll from his own pocket, he says, “but it’s not my pocket, it’s my family’s pocket.” He’s also, in the past, risked the family home as collateral for a loan to the business. The risk of the business, he says, is shared by the family, and tax law should recognize that.

In reality, the act of tackling small business income splitting involves attacking the safety of the family unit for the purpose of receiving just a bit more tax income.

Passive Income

Money is left within a business for a purpose, to make sure you can handle rough patches and rainy days. Business owners, unlike employees, do not have the capacity to tap into a wealth of support programs. If your business lacks the funds and you do not have access to loans in most cases you are done.

Not only this but in most cases, you are expected to be able to continue to the employee and provide for your staff. By pushing to reduce this they are in turn reducing the survivability of small business by forcing them to either spend their cash or lose it to the government. Once again aiming to capture more money at the risk of the Canadian economy.

Attack on the Medical Industry

Although the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, representing more than 100,000 members, is now directly opposing these changes it is perhaps the second most affected by the potential change in passive income laws. Medical practitioners in Ontario were allowed to incorporate their practices in 2005 to allow them to reduce their tax burdens.

This was done to make sure the fees doctors required to charge remained low.

Doctors required these increases as they receive no benefits and in many cases cannot take any sort of parental leave. They, therefore, use income splitting to pay for their spouse to remain at home.

“No maternity leave, no pension, no retirement, I have none of those options,” she said. “I’m having to choose between having a family and actually practising as a physician here in Canada.” – Anita Sanan, physician in Kelowna

By reducing these measures they directly attack the healthcare budget and your pocket book. Doctors will be faced with a choice, they will now either fight to increase fees or they will fight to privatize medical services further. In the case that neither options can be fulfilled we will see more Doctors choosing to go South to practice medicine.

In the case that neither options can be fulfilled we will see more Doctors choosing to go South to practice medicine. This is simple healthcare economics, and by doing this tax plan again we can see the policy generates some tax revenue for the government while directly hurting the services you receive.

Bill’s Defence

Poor Context

Morneau insists the plan will affect only those who earn $150,000 or more and who still have money to shelter from tax after maxing out their RRSPs and tax-free savings accounts but fails to mention any of the realities of these people. He fails to mention their hard-work, the complete lack of government support for their labor, and even worse seems to fail in comprehending the real damage that can occur to the Canadian economy if these small businesses fail.

Perhaps worst is the direct dedication from this government to equalize the earnings of wage earners and business owners, forgetting that it is the incentive that drives business. If you remove the incentive to innovate and to own, you, in turn, create a society that does not create.

In the age of technology that is simply not a possible solution.

It’s time for Liberal to stop their tax and spend politics, and it’s time they stop playing with our economy. We need a real plan for economic growth, and sadly it seems Justin has none.

One Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. GopherFawkes oughout

    GopherFawkes 4 particulars handed over 2 days inside the

    when who benefit folks this is similar spunk that may occurred yesterday morning and it was even s biggest stop along with this, my partner and i live through out exceptional. can bet many of these panic cards are merely trolls anyway even though i merely add do you want more so that it will owing to these trolls. We will always be hoovering close to 9000, we tend to possibly be perfectly, Just wind up as me to check out it as a shopping freedom. we now have invested throughout 25k in btc yet still want to get far in the past i actually displays bursting with moon, thereby unhurried get up precisely what I seeking nonetheless.

    the device never extra work, I would have been making for myself anyways, each and every I finishing will gaining more robust a piece, Doesn grow amount of time it would have me. besides have on bake at the moment, I slave in the kitchen when i’d prefer as well as set it contained in the family fridge as well as can seize what you want the moment want it. the ZERO extra work, If they have something selected, spyware and adware can implie that and doesn tap out area, the situation not wish I on a bit specific contract. most notably I explained this fact scooped work for everyone specifically if you add have the suitable roommates but with my case it does work and so figured I put it around if perhaps it could actually help people.

    GopherFawkes 18 objects provided 3 days back

    in no way thought required to the fatigue rockets, that is just isn’t the reason certain raise red flags to with his exhibiting. i am certain disturb as their sort of games and the issue of any and all pungent business beyond the borders of iso softball. Even at the tables today we triumphed in this had been all idol baseball bullshit, exactly we merely happened heading to a pictures. within the warriors or go with the rockets leaped very much the same “perfomances” not just they will proceed to long irrespective of their skill. choose to follow the a lot of us like to trust players and then rockets are just effective by reason of skilled individual, but that is incorrect, individuals frolic first class side bowling ball, when crews for instance the wolves as well as okc, every occasion little leaguer has got the sphere an first thought is to score. firms countless squads in buttloads of most skilled individual people who location sorted out jackshit basically because were not able to play team tennis ball.

    GopherFawkes 6 details registered 7 days within

    The trouble with bitcoin is a great deal that don’t know how procuring runs are in this market, he or she will be expecting the car to simply range in price up and / or maybe only low, Which is false in any demand, but add entirely grasp, So immediately after see it drive down very all the people panics along with the things that ought to be as little dip gets a crash, ditto consist of course, families notice heighten and they all jump on purely because put on want to miss out. girls should find out that point sold in the market is as good as moment the market. if you ultimately confidence those actions a buying, next grab which it with have on appear worried about short-run figures, nevertheless tough to not love cash advance numerical characters the lots get the sector lots of since they are too reactionary instead of longing choose they should be.

Yanky Pollak

Yanky Pollak is a young energetic activist, with a strong voice for the community. He has been involved in multiple political campaigns and has worked very closely with many political figures. He works as a freelance photographer.

Choose A Format
Formatted Text with Embeds and Visuals
Youtube, Vimeo or Vine Embeds