Categories: AnalysisCultureOpinionPolitics

Listen Liberals, Canadians are Tired of Identity Politics

Mandate that women make up half of your cabinet?

Push legislation, not for pay equality, but pay equity?

Codify into law that Canadians must use individual’s preferred gender pronoun?

These propositions from Justin Trudeau and the Liberal Party are based on the idea that the proper way of viewing and differentiating people is by gender, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.

This is identity politics and it is pathological to the core.

Here are three reasons why.

First, statistically, people differ inside groups more than groups differ from each other. This means that while understanding group differences are useful when trying to grasp scoping societal changes, attempting to apply those concepts down to individuals is wrong.

It is simply not accurate to assume that individuals believe, think, or act in a certain way based on the attributes of the category they belong to.

In light of this fact, a second issue becomes transparent when dealing with identity politics. Who gets to determine what each group believes? Does one simply pick a person at random with the faith that they represent the group they belong to? This doesn’t work and there are serious ramifications when trying to determine what a group may believe.

In 2016, University of Toronto professor Jordan Peterson vocally and publicly challenged Bill C16. The legislation was designed to prohibit discrimination based on gender identity but Peterson retaliated against it based on the legal implications that it would have on free speech. He was lambasted as being transphobic and hateful however what many people don’t know is that Peterson has gotten many letters from trans individuals stating that they agreed with him. This fact may seem strange with only a casual glance at the issue, but it illustrates that assuming the opinions of a community can be wildly erroneous.

On the subject of groups, we run into a third problem. How many categories can be made? What happens when an individual belongs to multiple categories? When the subject of privilege and oppression comes up, as often does when discussing identity politics, which group can claim more oppression? Is having a mental illness a category or group? What about a physical illness? Is having parents who are still together an identifiable category? What about good-looking people?

Simply run with the idea of group differences and clearly, groups and identity can be fractionated further and further down until the only logical explanation is that the individual is the correct way to understand humans beings.

Maybe most Canadians couldn’t care less about the philosophical aspects of identity politics but Canadians do know messed up ideas when they see them.

Canadians are tired of this ideological bend of not taking individuals by their merits, but classing people based on whatever social group fits for the day. Canadians are tired of a Liberal government assuming it knows what Canadians think based a single attribute like race, sex or income status.

Canadians are tired of an ever-expanding LGBTQQIP2SAA acronym and radical buzzwords like intersectionality and heteronormative being tossed around when discussing legislation that affects them personally.

Canadians are tired of identity politics and we are looking for something real, something authentic that can represent a future for all.

Jacob Valk

I do the Youtube thing and I am on all the social medias @itsthevalk.


Recent Posts

Conversation, Not Censorship Is the Path YouTube Should Follow

The only way to defeat bad ideas is with better ideas.

3 hours ago

Does the Conservative party have a future in Quebec? What about the immigration debate? An interview with Benjamin Tremblay PART 2

The future of the Conservative party in Quebec is diminished by Maxime Bernier's new party

18 hours ago

Scrapped! Ford government tears down Wynne’s costly Green Energy Act

Conservative Premier Doug Ford officially announces plan to repeal the Liberal government's Green Energy Act.

20 hours ago

America’s Congressional deadline to finalize NAFTA deal nearing, Canadian Foreign Minister will not settle

Foreign Affairs Minister, Chrystia Freeland, has revealed to reporters in Washington that her intention to maintain NAFTA is rooted on…

1 day ago

Is Trudeau serious about developing the Trans-Mountain pipeline?

Although PM Justin Trudeau assures the public that the Trans-Mountain expansion will be completed, his political alliances are casting doubt…

2 days ago

5 big Trudeau military failures

Here are only five of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s worst military failures throughout his term as Prime Minister and Liberal…

3 days ago