Categories: AnalysisB.C. NewsCanadian NewsOpinion

Legal defense fund launched for Chilliwack school trustee Barry Neufeld

In Chilliwack, British Columbia – about a one-hour drive out of Vancouver – school board trustee Barry Neufeld has become one of the only voices on the Board of Education willing to openly criticize BC’s controversial SOGI 123 curriculum.

SOGI 123, which stands for “sexual orientation and gender identity”, is a set of educational resources to teach students from kindergarten to Grade 12 about gender identity, gender pronouns, gender stereotypes, social justice, and family diversity, among other topics.

Though teaching SOGI 123 is not mandatory, teachers are encouraged to make use of the lesson plans and worksheets. Neufeld claimed he specifically takes issue with “the teaching of the theory, as if it was fact, that gender is fluid, that there are more than two genders, and that gender is not based in biology.” In October 2017, Neufeld wrote a Facebook post saying that letting children choose their gender is “child abuse” – a remark for which he later apologized.

Many are now trying to intimidate Neufeld out of his position. BC Education Minister Rob Fleming has called on Neufeld to resign; BC Teachers’ Federation President Glen Hansman said that Neufeld must either “step down or be pushed out, one way or the other”, and the Chilliwack School District board voted in January 2018 to urge Neufeld to resign after the Chilliwack Teachers’ Association called on Neufeld to be officially denounced for expressing opinions in violation of the BC Human Rights Code.

Additionally, the Maple Ridge school board declined to host a BC School Trustee Association meeting in February because Neufeld, as a sitting school trustee himself, intended to attend. The Maple Ridge school board claimed Neufeld had publicly expressed views that contravene their “Safe, Caring, and Healthy Schools” policy, and therefore they could not allow him to attend a meeting within their district.

According to the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, Neufeld became aware of a human rights complaint against himself and the Chilliwack School District in January 2018. The complaint was filed by the Canadian Union of Public Employees Local 411 (CUPE 411), which represents approximately 800 School District support staff.

CUPE 411 claims that the School District has violated the BC Human Rights Code by not censuring or removing Neufeld as a trustee, and that Neufeld’s statements have created an “unsafe” and “discriminatory” working environment for employees. CUPE 411 filed the human rights complaint without first consulting its local members.

Because the human rights complaint arose from Neufeld’s activities as a school trustee, the BC Public Sector Employer’s Association is retaining a lawyer for him. However, Neufeld is launching a separate case to defend himself from the “slanderous” attacks on his character by the Ministry of Education, the President of the BC Teachers’ Federation, the Maple Ridge School Board, and the Chilliwack School Board.

A legal defence fund has been set up to assist with Neufeld’s legal costs. The crowdfunding campaign has been set up by the elusive “Coalition of Concerned Canadians”, who do not maintain a web presence or name themselves. According to the anonymous campaign organizer, the Coalition is a group of “ordinary people” who have decided to “take action in preserving our democracy and free speech” but do not want to risk being harassed by going public. All donations to the campaign have so far been anonymous.

Although many may feel Neufeld’s legal defence is worth raising money for, they are seemingly unwilling to publicly put their name to such a politically incorrect cause: Neufeld says the person who set up the crowdfunding campaign doesn’t want their employer to find out, as they believe they may lose their job.

Despite spending his career working with at-risk youth, Neufeld is now not allowed to go into the schools of the district he was elected to represent. At the high school graduation ceremonies this past June, he was not permitted to go on stage and hand out scholarships.

And though he was supposed to deliver the graduation speech at Sardis Secondary School this year, he was told by the school principal he would no longer be allowed to do so, as it “might upset an LGBTQ+ student on their special day.”

While Neufeld was originally not planning on running again for trustee, saying he was “getting tired of the way school trustees were being side-lined by the unions and the bureaucrats in the Provincial government”, he now plans to run for re-election in October 2018, after seeing that so many people value his voice on the Chilliwack board of education, which so many others are viciously trying to censor.


  • > Neufeld wrote a Facebook post saying that letting children choose their gender is “child abuse” – a remark for which he later apologized.

    He shouldn't have apologized. It *is* child abuse.

  • This is just another example of how our children are being brainwashed by the so-called education system! It's time for the incompetent teachers to get the boot and be replaced by those that have the ability to teach the basics along with common sense. Not saying all teachers are misemployed but most are. What they are teaching today is indeed child abuse. Where are the parents in all this? Probably heads down over their damned phones! Where can I make a donation for Neufeld's defense?

  • The rather shameful behaviour by many in B.C.’s “Education” department gives some weight to the argument – by both Barbara Kay and Brendan O’Neill – that “Questioning gender fluidity is the new blasphemy”.

    However, the credibility of such questioning and of Neufeld’s own taking issue with “the teaching of the theory, as if it was fact, that gender is fluid, that there are more than two genders, and that gender is not based in biology” kind of hinges on precisely what is meant by the term “gender”.

    And, rather unfortunately, that seems the bone of contention as many – Dr. Debra Soh for example – rather dogmatically insist that “biological sex and gender are binary” while many others – Wikipedia and various dictionaries for examples – argue, with far more justification, that it is, as Merriam-Webster asserts, “the behavioral, cultural, or psychological traits typically associated with one sex”. And that latter position might reasonably justify viewing gender as a spectrum, although “fluidity” might be questionable, at least that it is more fluid than molasses.

    So while sex is certainly binary – male or female – which is by definition determined only by the type of gametes we produce, it is a bit of a stretch to insist that all of those traits are uniquely determined only by our sexes. Or by whether we even have a sex as there is a not insignificant percentage of the population that don’t actually have a sex, and who, presumably, still exhibit a range of “behavioral, cultural, or psychological traits”.

    But the problems tend to mushroom because many people are apparently conflating sex and gender – if they’re not two separate categories or classes then why do we even need the latter? – and think and argue that because gender is, to some extent, “fluid” people can therefore change their sex as easily as they might change those “behavioral, cultural, or psychological traits”. But, until science figures out a way to transplant ovaries and testicles into those who were born without them or who were born with gonads of a different type, no one ever changes their sex – except maybe from “male” or “female” to “none”.

    Those interested in an elaboration on those themes might check out my own Post Millennial article on the topic: A discussion on the Transgender issue.

Published by
Lindsay Shepherd

Recent Posts

  • Politics

Liberal Defence Minister spent more than what 95% of Canadians make in a year on photos

Canadian Taxpayers spent $161,000 for photographers to take images of Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan on his many national and international…

41 mins ago
  • Canadian News
  • Discussion
  • Indigenous
  • Politics

Human trafficking happens in Canada everyday. Let’s talk about it.

People are shocked to learn that 93% of Canada’s trafficking victims come from within Canada.

17 hours ago
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Politics

The Rise of the Rabble-Rousers and the Assault on Reason

Portraying herself as a warrior for conservatism while doing all she can to sabotage it, Candace Owens is the right’s…

17 hours ago
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Politics

RuPaul’s show proves that identity politics is a drag

I went to a gay bar with my girlfriend on Friday and watched the finale of RuPaul's Drag Race. It…

18 hours ago
  • Canadian News
  • Politics

Jody Wilson-Raybould’s father says Butts resignation is a case of “trying to keep reputation clean”

"The reality is that we seem to be getting closer to the Emperor and he doesn't seem to have any…

18 hours ago
  • Canadian News
  • Politics

Gerald Butts only met with SNC-Lavalin once, and it was in 2017

Although Butts only met once with SNC-Lavalin, the meeting broached the topic of "justice and law enforcement".

19 hours ago